the pants did turn out huge, but the shirt not so much. The pants fit John and the shirt is so small, it's too small for Finn. (Here's John very reluctantly modeling the pants. This is the only pic I could get on him, he had them off right away. The poor guy's skin is really dry from the cold, and no matter how much we put lotion on, it's still dry, so he insists on being naked all the time.) I don't understand how the sizes could be so off in the same pattern. Maybe that's why it was only 50 cents. So John has another pair of pants he doesn't need and Finn will be able to fit them in the summer when he doesn't need them and the shirt will probably be cut up for scraps.